Home Care

Home Care

Photo above: Brushwood Care Home in Speke

Two council-built care homes in Liverpool have gone bust, leaving 83 families scrambling to find homes for their loved ones. But why did the council allow a private company to run these homes, and what should they do now?

By Ritchie Hunter

Shaw Healthcare, who were given the contract to operate these £8m care homes – Brushwood in Speke and Millvina in Everton – have said that Covid-19 has led to unsustainable losses. So because they’re not making enough profit – typically between 20 to 30% – lives are put in danger and 132 jobs threatened.

Shaw Healthcare was co-founded by Julian Foulger, who is the senior principal of the Grand Cascade Group. Their website ‘Mission’ is to ‘engage in the acquisition and management of outstanding care homes both in the UK and internationally’. They claim that this is a ‘growing market’ in a ‘recession proof sector’ where their ‘real estate portfolio’ ‘provides safety and collaterals’ for their investors.

Welcome to the Private Equity world, where companies see the care sector as a ‘cash cow’. They now operate 13% of residential and nursing homes, with 56,700 beds. But, because of the pandemic, their investments are not making money and they’re struggling to survive.

It’s our aged and infirm relatives who are counting the cost – in lives. Forty per cent of care homes in England have been hit by Covid-19, brought on mainly by the transfer of the elderly from hospitals without testing or safety provision. Thousands of deaths, including many care workers, is the result. This crisis can only get worse, as Private Equity companies face financial ruin; although it’s likely they’ll be bailed out by this incompetent government, whose privatisation policies make the Covid-19 disaster much worse.

Of course there are many well run care homes who have remained safe. Which is another reason not to bail-out the equity companies. That would send the message ‘business as usual’ and mean more privatisation and misery.

For Liverpool Council the message is clear. Instead of shuffling our elderly around with dwindling resources, stand up to the government and insist on council-run care homes. Any bailout money should be used to improve care for the old and conditions for the workers. They should organise a fight back against privatisation and force the government to provide the means for safe and healthy care, free from stress and worry for everyone.

Be reasonable, demand the impossible!



  1. There is a further problem. Why build this model of care in the first place? It looks like a prison. In the private sector it was the model required to make a profit, not necessarily the best model for the people who need additional support. Councils should be looking at small community hubs, designed on the basis of real co-production involving the users, front line workers and families and friends. Only small homely community living with garden and green space and fresh air, linked to workers that can provide support to people living in their own homes. Large institutions have proved to be even more unsafe as a result Covid-19 with more deaths in 60 bedded establishments compared to the small 30 bedded units. Do you want to live out your days in one of these institutions?


  2. Totally agree with Ann’s comments. We need the type of care homes she describes- small, homely, with gardens for residents to enjoy and help take care of if they wish- with the needs of residents the main consideration, not profit- making.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Please answer this (to remove spam) *