The Lady In The Van (12A)
by Nicholas Hytner
From 13th November 2015
Maggie Smith has been touted as a possible Oscar winner for her role in this
film but I am not sure why. OK it's a impressive performance by the veteran
actress, more accustomed to playing middle-class types, but without seeming
to be unkind she has had plenty of preparation in playing this character.
She first appeared in the part in a stage production in 1999 and then
later in a radio production.
Supposedly based on real-life events, some of what occurs is pure fantasy
by Alan Bennett. The movie is adapted from his memoir, published in the
London Review of Books, about the woman, Miss Shepherd, who lived in a
camper van in his driveway for fifteen years.
For instance, it shows the time in her life when she was a nun, and then,
hey presto, she is later seen performing majestically on the piano at
a Proms concert. Or was it the other way round?! From performing at the
Proms to becoming a nun?
More absurd fantasy takes place when, after being placed in a care home
for a brief spell, as a result of falling ill in her van, she enters an
empty room wherein lies a piano. At eighty-years-old, and not having played
the musical instrument for many years - and more than likely having arthritic
hands - after a couple of false starts, and without any sheet music to
guide her, she begins to play with effortless precision as in her heyday.
Nonsense in the extreme.
Taking part in the film are a lot of stock characters or cartoon strip
characters, call it what you will. For example, Francis de la Tour is
cast as an eccentric woman, surprise, surprise! Apparently, but I was
not aware of this when viewing the film, some of the characters resemble
those featured in Bennett's 1960s cartoon series The Stringal.
One of the most impressive aspects was the use of two Alan Bennetts,
both ably played by Alex Jennings, conversing with each other. The other
one being an alter ego, examining himself and his actions.
In particular, and Bennett did question himself why he did it, what made
him choose to allow a bad-tempered, ungrateful woman, who he could hardly
call a friend or even an acquaintance, to live in his driveway for many
years, but readily puts his mother, who is starting to suffer from dementia,
into a care home.
Perhaps there was more material for his plays to be gained from Miss
Shepherd rather than his dull and characterless mother.
NERVE supports workers struggling for a living wage.